withjamie

Is Short Form Content Oversaturated?

Have Any Questions?

I’m ready to listen and help with anything you may need.

jamie@withjamie.co.uk

(+44) 7787 335245

short form video content

Short-form video saw its first surge of popularity with the introduction of Vine in 2013, but the true rise came in late 2019 and early 2020, with TikTok dominating the market and other platforms such as Instagram and YouTube following suit to capitalise on this trend.

But now, after over 6 years, is the short form oversaturated? It is a core part of many brands’ marketing strategies, but diluted by numerous individual posts. On TikTok alone, 34 million videos are posted each day

Are you late to the party, or do you still have a chance?

What is Saturation?

Saturated content occurs when multiple users post similar content within a niche or industry, competing for top placement. This creates a firm barrier to entry, making it harder for new users to gain traction or attention. This is driven by high global demand for content that exceeds current supply levels.

The Facts

Around 91% of marketers are expected to use short-form videos
Short-form videos receive 2.5 times more engagement than long-form videos

91% of Instagram users now watch videos on the platform weekly

As of late 2025, YouTube Shorts have generated over 9 trillion cumulative views since becoming available

66% of consumers find short-form videos the most engaging content type

What We Know

Social Media as a Search Engine

A widely known fact is that social media is increasingly becoming a search engine. Instead of relying on Google, people trust video content when making a purchase decision. 73% of consumers prefer short-form videos for product and service searches, and 57% of Gen Z prefer them for learning about products and services

Optimising your short-form content to directly answer user searches can help you rank higher in feeds and boost engagement. Asking questions such as ‘Is this worth it?’ or making statements such as ‘I didn’t enjoy X because…’ answers user searches and therefore increases the chance of your video being viewed.

SEO is seemingly becoming less and less important, with AI Engine Optimisation (AEO) and now Social Media Search Optimisation (SMSO) taking priority as consumers make this shift. For marketers and individuals, this trend emphasises the importance of short-form videos.

Niche Content Reigns

Focusing on a niche is vital for engagement and building a strong audience. Staying consistent with this niche will strengthen retention and engagement, as people will know to expect a certain type of content from you, creating recurring viewers.

Often, people switch niches because they’re not seeing results, even though it takes time for results to compound. It is important to allow the algorithm to understand your content and then appropriately distribute it. By constantly switching your content, you’re only delaying the process.

Format repetition is important here. Simply put, you reuse the same video format but change the topic each time. This creates a pattern across your page that not only the algorithm will recognise, but also your audience will. Pick your highest performing video(s), and repeat that technique. It’s not laziness, it’s intention.

What the Algorithm Favours

Long ago, the algorithm favoured volume. If you posted frequently, your content reached more people. Whilst this isn’t entirely untrue nowadays, the algorithm also considers content quality, using signals such as high watch time, low bounce rate, share levels, and meaningful interactions (comments rather than likes alone).

This means creators place greater emphasis on producing high-quality content. Educational content has always been good at keeping retention high, and you can use that to your advantage. Answer questions and demonstrate helpful/interesting elements of your product or service. Doing so will also help with your SMSO.

Algorithms test your content in small pools before scaling, so it’s important that you retain this small group so your content can be pushed out to and reach more people.

Attention Spans Are Dwindling

The average attention span for adults is 8.25 seconds (less than a goldfish!). This means screen time is finite: although the average person spends 6 hours a day online, much of that is spent scrolling through hundreds or thousands of videos, not just yours.

It is important to have a strong hook in your videos so users get the information they need to be intrigued and want to watch more. Users decide within 3 seconds whether to watch the video, making this a crucial moment.

When you’re on the Explore or For You page, you’re not just competing against your niche; you’re competing against everyone else. This is why ensuring your videos are captivating is even more important.

The Rise of AI

Since its mainstream media introduction in 2022, AI has seen significant growth in power and capability. Now, AI models can script, edit, caption, and repurpose your content, which can significantly increase content supply, further boosting saturation.

As AI models are trained on existing high-performing content and information, there is the risk that all AI content can follow too similar of a pattern, putting it at risk of being samey. This is fortunate for us, as it allows us to differentiate from the crowd simply by being human.

Recently, there has been a growing demand for authenticity and ‘messiness’ – basically just human interaction. You should capitalise on this by showing your personality and the human parts of your business or life.

Is Short-Form Content Oversaturated?

Short-form content isn’t oversaturated; low-effort content is. Some creators post low-effort content, but brands usually cannot avoid it. To stand out, you must have a strategy to differentiate yourself from low-quality content.

Authentic content is often thought of as low-effort, but this is not the case. A growing demand for authenticity across short-form content apps means that you can utilise this for your brand. Showing your personality as a founder or staff member is great for engagement, as long as it is strategically aligned with your brand goals and current trends in your niche.

There remains a deficit, with demand for short-form content significantly outweighing supply. This means that short-form content literally cannot be oversaturated at this stage. However, some niches can be more saturated than others, so it’s important to do your research to avoid shooting in the dark.

If you’d like to discuss a personalised social media strategy for your business, please get in touch.

Client

Northshore Dental

Overview

Northshore Dental is a modern private dental clinic offering general and cosmetic dental services. Here, I created a Home Page design focusing on calls to action and building trust.

Scope of Work

  • Logo creation
  • UX/UI redesign
  • Typography & colour system
  • Full copywriting
  • Graphic design

Solutions

The brief emphasised reassuring nervous clients and creating the impression of a comforting, relaxing dental studio. The main goal was to build trust and funnel that into increased bookings. To do this, I used neutral colours and minimalist visual elements and typography to avoid feeling overly clinical or daunting.

Final Outcome

The homepage provides reassurance to patients and focuses on the appointment booking CTA. The calming design helps address Northshore’s challenge of earning client trust.

instagram and facebook growth statistics

Results

60,000+ Views | 9,000 Reach | 50% Increased Clicks

Overview

The Personalised Flower Box is a local florist. Pauline discussed wanting to grow her audience as she moved towards a new niche. Her focus was on showcasing her personality, which we achieved through static and video content I produced.

Scope of Work

  • Branding & identity
  • Social strategy
  • Consistent posting
  • Photo editing & graphic design
  • Audience engagement

Process

Pauline provided me with static content, which I edited and adapted to align with her relevant strategy. These were posted twice a week across Facebook and Instagram.

Simultaneously, I produced and edited long-form video content for Pauline, which was posted on YouTube and gained traction with the second video, with clients noting it was useful and entertaining.

Results

Pauline saw significant growth across her social media platforms. Increased engagement and reach on Instagram and Facebook led to more traffic to her website, and Pauline noted a noticeable increase in sales and enquiries.

Tutorials posted on YouTube helped attendees of her workshops understand wreath making, making classes smoother, more efficient, and more engaging.

Results

152,000 Followers | 1,000,000+ Engagement

Overview

During lockdown, I created a themed Instagram account. It was a growing, competitive niche, so I had to learn how to adapt to the community and its expectations. What began as a hobby turned into a thriving community and business that lasted just under half a decade.

Scope of Work

  • Branding & identity creation
  • E-commerce store
  • Social strategy & posting
  • Audience engagement
  • Branded advertisements 

Results

In just 12 months, I grew this account to over 100,000 followers, reaching 150,000 only a few months later. At its peak, my daily posts were receiving up to 75,000, and the page was attracting more than 1 million monthly visitors.

I am incredibly proud of the community I created. I hosted giveaways, developed a merch line, partnered with brands for paid advertisements and received hundreds of messages from people sharing what the page meant to them. 

In January 2024, I took the step to stop posting. Rather than selling the account, despite receiving several strong offers, I decided to leave the page as a digital time capsule that people, including myself, can return to forever. 

This project is one of my favourite examples of what good strategy, consistency, and creativity can achieve. It’s also the basis of the work I do for clients: helping them to build brands, content and communities that genuinely resonate and grow. 

Client

ClearLedge

Overview

ClearLedger is a speculative modern accounting platform for non-finance founders who don’t understand traditional accounting tools. Here, I was tasked with Home Page design, focusing on visual hierarchy, calls to action and building trust.

Scope of Work

  • Logo creation
  • UX/UI redesign
  • Typography & colour system
  • Full copywriting
  • Graphic design

Solutions

I prioritised ensuring the site didn’t feel daunting or too corporate by using minimalistic colouring and typography. White and light blue create a fresh, sleek feel.

I focused on CTAs to align with the main goal of increasing free-trial signups among first-time visitors. Furthermore, this goal made trustworthiness and credibility paramount, which I ensured through social proof and human support cues. 

Final Outcome

The homepage communicates trust and reliability, making the daunting topic of finances more accessible for non-finance founders.

Client

The Personalised Flower Box

Overview

Pauline Brunsdon, at The Personalised Flower Box, expressed a desire to rebrand her business ahead of opening an E-Commerce store and YouTube channel. The existing visuals of her website were inconsistent and unclear, making for a difficult user journey and experience and failing to communicate value quickly. 

Scope of Work

  • Logo creation
  • UX/UI redesign
  • Typography & colour system
  • E-commerce setup & launch
  • Rewrites of key messaging

Solutions

To solve these issues, I began by designing a sleek yet on-theme logo, as well as a smaller version for the favicon and social media profile pictures. I composed set typography and colour schemes to use across platforms, creating a more cohesive and recognisable brand identity.

Refining the User Experience and Interface (UX/UI) improved professionalism and built trust from a visitors first impression. Furthermore, a cleaner structure made browsing faster, easier and more enjoyable.

Final Outcome

Pauline was delighted with her new website and branding. Post-launch, she saw an increase in engagement across her website and social media platforms. This has led to an ongoing collaboration for social media and website management.